Crushed Boxes, Missing Parcels and the Refunds Nobody Files

There are so many moving parts in supply chain that I’m not one bit surprised that filing claims with parcel carriers slips past a lot of companies, but it leaves way more money on the table than most people think. You’re not just out the product, you’re paying to reship it, and in the worst case you’re spending time and money winning back a customer who’s now side-eyeing your brand because their order showed up in pieces or didn’t show at all.

Most companies have a little graveyard of boxes somewhere out there, the ones that never showed up or arrived looking like they’d been through a wood chipper, and the usual move is to eat the loss, reship and move on. Reshipping is the right thing to do, of course, but if that’s where it ends, you are missing out on real money that is owed to you.

Parcel claims are one of the only places in shipping where money flows back toward the shipper instead of away from them, and a surprising number of companies leave it sitting on the table. A UK analysis from Claimit, a claims recovery platform, found that over 40% of UK retailers never file for lost or damaged shipments at all, which they estimate adds up to as much as £2.1 billion a year in unclaimed refunds. Canada is not doing any better, considering lost mail and fights over compensation made up 43% of everything Canada Post’s Ombudsman investigated in 2024.

Nobody is going to refund you automatically

Carriers do not go looking for their own mistakes. UPS, FedEx, Purolator, USPS, and Canada Post are not going to notice your parcel got crushed in a sort facility and send you an e-transfer. So every eligible claim has to be spotted, documented and filed by you. And it’s on you, not your customer, because Canada Post only takes claims from the sender, and while UPS, FedEx and USPS will let a recipient get the ball rolling, it’s still the shipper who usually ends up chasing the invoices, photos, and sign-offs it takes to get paid.

The default coverage is also smaller than most people assume. UPS and FedEx include $100 of liability on a standard package and Purolator does the same at $100 CAD, so anything worth more than that is only covered if you paid to declare a higher value when you made the label. Declared value isn’t insurance either, it’s just the carrier agreeing to a higher ceiling on what they might owe you, and they still get to argue with you about whether they owe it.

Timing Is Everything

This is where most of the money disappears, because claim windows are short and the carriers don’t bend on them. The clocks look like this:

  • UPS: 60 days from the scheduled delivery date for domestic shipments

  • FedEx Express (US): 60 days from the ship date

  • FedEx international: 21 days from delivery

  • USPS: 60 days from the mailing date, and only on insured packages (Priority Mail and Ground Advantage include $100 of coverage by default)

  • Canada Post: about 90 days for domestic lost and damaged parcels, plus 30 business days from the guaranteed delivery date for late delivery refunds on guaranteed services like Priority and Xpresspost

Miss the window and the claim gets denied as untimely; no appeal, no sympathy. So if your process is “we’ll go through claims at the end of the quarter,” what you actually have is a process for not getting paid.

Filing too fast can backfire

Surprisingly, panicking and filing a claim too soon can also hurt you. ShipScience looked at roughly 257,000 loss claims and found that claims filed in the first week after shipping were paid less than 30% of the time, while claims filed between 8 and 45 days out were paid 71 to 78% of the time. The reason is pretty boring once you see it: a carrier won’t treat a package as lost until it’s missed its delivery date and a trace has come up empty, so if you file before then, they can just point to their own tracking. ShipScience found nearly 40% of those first-week claims were denied because the scans showed the box as delivered or no signature was required. It’s a bit like baking bread, where pulling it out early means it collapses and leaving it too long means it’s charcoal.

Read your contract for a claims waiver

If you have negotiated rates with a carrier, go dig out the agreement and look for anything about waiving claims. Some shippers agree to give up their right to file in exchange for a better discount, usually because chasing claims felt like more hassle than it was worth, and it’s exactly the kind of clause that gets signed during a rate negotiation and forgotten about by the time the first crushed box rolls in.

What a real strategy looks like

It starts with somebody owning it, because claims that belong to everyone end up belonging to no one. That person or team needs a process for the moment a customer reaches out about a damaged order, which means asking them right away to hang onto the box, the inner packaging and the product, and to send photos of the outside of the box and everything inside it, since carriers can ask to inspect the damage. On your end, keep your cost invoices handy, because proof of value is the first thing every carrier asks for. Also before shipping make sure to pack to the carrier’s own guidelines, because inadequate packaging is one of the most common reasons claims get denied, even on the free $100. If you ship anything pricey or fragile, snapping a quick photo of how it was packed before it goes out the door gives you something to push back with if the carrier blames your packaging.

Then track your deadlines by carrier and service, and follow up on what you’ve filed, because a lot of claims never get formally denied. They just get a case number and sit in a queue until everyone forgets about them. If your volume is high enough that this turns into a part-time job, a claims recovery service might pay for itself, and ShipScience estimates eligible lost and damaged claims run about 2 to 3% of parcel spend for high-volume shippers.

“Almost every shipper we talk to says claims are already handled, either by someone on their team or by their audit vendor,” says James Sutton, CTO of ShipScience. “Then we look at their data and find a pile of lost and damaged packages nobody ever filed. Nobody dropped the ball on purpose. It just wasn’t really anyone’s job to verify.”

A hundred bucks here and there doesn’t feel worth the paperwork, which is exactly why so many companies skip it and what carriers are hoping for. But add up a year of crushed boxes and missing parcels and you’re looking at real money, and that’s your money. Don’t just leave it there.

Next
Next

Girls’ Girls Work In Supply Chain: Shirley Liu